Quote:
I'm sorry Neil but I'm not going to make any apologies for my role allocation. I cannot predictably rotate who get's powers because then it becomes too easy to metagame. This is why I made you mafia two out of three times, because other players might not have expected that.
I don't really think language such as "really quite crappy", "variety would have been nice", "quite disheartening", "really tedious after a while", "makes me feel a bit miffed" etc is particularly kind to me and I don't think it's at all courteous to have gotten "upset with the game".
Well as I said before, its up to you to take it how you take it. Obviously you are upset that someone has decided to criticize the game that you have run.
All I was doing was trying to be honest with how I felt the game was being done in relation to myself and I honestly felt a bit hard done by by the roles I had been given after 3 games in a row, as I have expressed in the above posts.
What would you rather I say? "Good show old chap however I felt a little upset that I had the same role 3 times?" By the sounds of it you were going to get upset and defensive regardless of how I would have said it. I thought I was being quite tame in the comments that I have posted and as I said I have been nothing but completely honest. Now to take it as a personnel attack on you or your abilities to run the game? Fine. Whatever. This is the last time I will try to be honest and attempt to try and show some criticism in relation to how a game is being run that I am a participant in.
Enjoy the rest of your mafia games guys. You will have one less participant to worry about.
Register
thanks again to Russia. This last game especially has been epic.
Looks awesome and I think I can manage to log on once a day every day (spending lots of time online would be the biggest obstacle for me though).